marvel.com
sign-in: (or register!)   user name: pass: remember me
help
Subscribe To Comics
blogs
Reader Questions 3
2009-05-28 17:28:57
It never ends! More answers to the questions you wanted to ask!
>1). In the August solicitation of Marvel Spotlight, it seems to mention events that we haven't yet heard of (the original Human Torch's return, a new Fantastic Four, and revisiting the Clone Saga in some form). Are these actually upcoming events? >
 
Yes, and you'll hear about them all further in teh coming months. We just announced THE TORCH, an 8-issue limited series masterminded by Alex Ross, the new FF refers to the oncoming creative team of Jonathan Hickman and Dale Eaglesham beginning with #570, and there'll be news about teh Clone Saga shortly.

>2). What is something that DC is currently doing or publishing that you wish Marvel was doing?

Posted by Asian_Pirate on 2009-05-22 21:03:49>
 
Employing Geoff Johns. Or should that be "renting" him?

> Is there any chance Marvel will get some other legacy characters anytime soon? I thought what you guys did with Cap took guts, and turned out quite well, even it it does just get undone by a certain book this year (although I hope it doesn't).

Posted by onefinemess on 2009-05-22 22:20:51>
 
There'll probably be an occasional legacy character here or there, but as a rule of thumb, I tend to think that these sorts of characters don't work as well in the Marvel mythology as they do elsewhere. The core of what makes Marvel Marvel is that the people inside the costume aer more important than the costume itself--so the idea that you could have a replacement Spider-Man or a replacement Thor of any duration just feels wrong. Cap is one of the few characters in the Marvel line for whom this sort of thing can work--and even then, it's only been succesful because we've been able to make readers interested and invested in james barnes, regardless of what outfit he's wearing.

> Why are there several gaps in the site's digital runs on many series? I understand that not every Marvel comic ever published can possibly be digitized, but some gaps leave me scratching my head. For example, the current Captain America series runs from issue #1 straight to issue #21 but then jumps to issue #26. That's a four issue gap that includes the famous death issue. This is one example of many similar gaps of important issues. Is this intentional? >
 
To be honest, I'm not entirely certain. I know that, on occasion, some material will rotate in and out and around that area of the site. It could be that we're planning to do something with the Death of Cap digital material online around the CAP #600 celebration or something--but I'm honestly not certain.

>I don't have a second question, but I would like to brag that I had the seriously cool pleasure of meeting Stan Lee today in Brentwood, CA!!!

Posted by punkfunkandjunk on 2009-05-23 01:17:50>
 
He's just as cool in real life, isn't he?

>1. What does it really take for a person to break into the Biz? I'm an Inker (and can do other positions of the CRAFT) and I've been trying for decades (I will not give up). I know at times it is being in the right place at the right time. I know it's networking like a madman. I know it involves a certain degree of talent. I know it's getting published elsewhere (the dreaded catch 22). I know of other things as well; however what I don't know or the information that I am lacking is enough to drive a dedicated person insane. I could use any insight that you might care to divulge to me and anyone else who cares to listen. Please. >
 
As I've said in the past, you need talent, perseverence and luck. But there's also a reality that some folks will need to face: not everybody is good enough to do this professionally. I obvioulsy can't judge your work blind, Reed, and I don't want to discourage you in your quest (since perseverence is one of teh three things I stress.) However, if you've been actively trying to break in for literally decades, and have gotten nowhere, then my first guess is that your work perhaps isn't as strong as you think it is. If you're doing everything else right (and you can be honest enough with yourself to have an idea of what you may be doing wrong) then the most obvious defecit that would keep you from finding success would be talent. I also find your comment about being published elsewhere as a Catch-22 as a sign of a problem. At Marvel, we hire the best people and maintain the highest overall standards--just a glance at our line should show that. If you do have the skills, though, you should have no difficulty finding a break among the minor leagues of independent publishing. Unless you'er simply not interested, and haven't been knocking on those doors. If that's the case, then perhaps you're not networking enough like a madman, and need to reassess where and how you're devoting your efforts. Nobody gets to start at the top in any business, so why would you think you could bypass paying your dues and learning your craft in the minors before we'd give you a shot? Every opportunity to get into print and hone your skills is an opportunity, and should be pursued. In any event, regardless of how negative this must sound, I wish you the best of luck.

>2. I have kind of fallen away from reading comics a bit and keeping up with the current books (Mostly due to economic reasons and 10+ years of attending SDCC [see above]) . I have 2 decades or better of most of the longer running titles. I started sliding back in 96 when I had some difficulties that affected me financially. the problem I have now is that I really don't like the direction that the line has taken since that point and I really doesn't make me want to jump back on board. (I had a similar problem in the 70's with Marvel. That and still being a kid then.) Any way I wanted to see about your opinion about when older readers start tapering off because they don't like what's being done. The argument is always "Change". However lately both major companies are just rehashing ideals and concepts that were done 20-30 or more years ago. it's not really change if it's been done in some form.

Posted by Reed Richards Prime on 2009-05-23 03:48:34>

This is sort of a broad question, but if I could pare it down to what I think you're saying, it's that you don't like the current state of the books in our line. And that's valid--not every comic book is for every reader, after all. And while I would hate to aim your attentions elsewhere, if what we're doing isn't floating your boat, there are dozens of publishers out there who are putting out a wide range of material--some of it may be more to your liking. Or there are always collections of the great storylines of the past--we've got more stuff available and in print in TPB and Hardcover form than at any time previous.I will take issue with the statement that al we're doing is rehashing ideas and concepts from the past--I don't think that's the case at all. If you publish any group of characters long enough, there are going to be certain themes and patterns that emerge historically over time. The trick is not to just do the same stories again and again, but to find new wrinkles in the material. On the surface, SECRET INVASION and the KREE/SKRULL WAR are both about aliens from outer space attacking the Earth, but they're very different stories. Still, your mileage may vary, and if you don't care for what we've been doing, no amount of carrying on by me is going to change your point of view.
 
>I am really enjoying the work of Tom and Ron on the Spectacular Spider-Girl. I was very disappointed when the Amazing Spider-Girl comic was cancelled earlier this year, but I was very excited when May and company received new life in the Spectacular Spider-Girl Digital comic!

With all the times that Spider-Girl has been cancelled over the years I am wondering if Spectacular Spider-Girl is finally 'safe' as a digital comic, or is there some criteria for her ongoing survival in the digital world.

The reason I ask this is Spectacular Spider-Girl stories are reprinted in Amazing Spider-man Family, yet there is no solicit for Amazing Spider-man Family in August. Does this bode ill for the the Spectacular Spider-Girl digital series?

Posted by tomek97 on 2009-05-23 05:06:07>
 
As I said yesterday, I don't think any book is ever 100% 'safe' at any point. Especially in the case of a series like SPIDER-GIRL, which has been dogged by the spectre of cancellation virtually since it was launched over a decade ago. Making the move to digital does change the game a little bit, though, when it comes to Mayday, and if we suddenly saw even 20% of the 20,000-or-so readers who always stood up to support her series when it was ready to be axed in the past start subscribing to the Digital Comics Unlimited program because there were new Spider-Girl stories to be had there, that would go a long way towards securing her future.

>.DnA have turned me into a total Cosmic nerd, any plans to add another cosmic book? >
 
There'll be some cool cosmic-related stuff exploding out of the climax of WAR OF KINGS. And the switchover of SKAAR to SON OF HULK ina few months should also scratch your cosmic itch in a completely different way.

>2. With the cancellation of Captain Britain, what book should I add to my pull list?

Posted by scott19438 on 2009-05-23 09:54:23>
 
I can't claim to know your tastes overall, but it seems to me that the people who were vocal about liking CAPTAIN BRITAIN AND MI:13 also seem to dig AGENTS OF ATLAS, another quirky, off-beat and distinctive super hero series set around the periphery of the Marvel U. So that might be a title to explore.

>when are we going to see a follow up to the marvel mystic arcana series? and, though I doubt I'll
thanks
Thanks tom, I will check out Agents! Let's hope it sticks around :) and I was reading Skaar but dropped it, will keep an eye on the upcoming solicits, gtg read Gaurdians 14 and Nova 25 have a great night!

Posted by scott19438 on 2009-05-28 22:13:47
For some reason, it looks like the Q&A is cut off at the Mystic Arcana question for me, anyone else have this problem?

Thanks for answering my questions Tom! I'm looking forward to the Torch mini and whatever you guys have cooking on the Clone Saga! And I agree that Geoff Johns needs to come back to Marvel, his time in the MU was too short!

Posted by Asian_Pirate on 2009-05-28 22:37:57
mystic question?
Is it just my browser or is the question "when are we going to see a follow up to the marvel mystic arcana series? and, though I doubt I'll" cut off and not answered?

Posted by beta-ray on 2009-05-29 00:05:54
I also have the same problem.

Posted by harlequin7 on 2009-05-29 09:04:16
Thank you for the Honest replies to my questi
In the case of the first question. I have indeed been doing what you point out in your answer. I just keep on looking at "What am I doing wrong", "What am I not Doing?" "What could I be doing?". I also haven't necessarily been at it consistantly thur those decades. I am in fact working in the minors now. It was just trying to get those opps that I was having some great difficulty with. So I do appreciate your candor on the subject. I have to examine what I've been doing.

as to # 2 I haven't recently enjoyed the current state of the books. Well not completely at least. There are some things I have been reading (but once again this is limited by my poor income.)
As to the rehashing I didn't necessarily mean for it to come off negatively. I meant that as you state that there are themes and patterns occur over time. I just find it funny that both Marvel and DC are hitting some of those strides simultaneously. I think I just want to care like I did. being largely away for a decade I guess I'm just wishing for what I feel is the glory days. This is not to say such is possible now days. I'm just finding it economically difficult to get back on board __and wanting to get back issues for back story. I want to read Spidey by JR. JR but I've missed so much.
Sorry if this came off sounding negative It wasn't meant to be. I guess I'm just missing comics.
Thanks tom

Posted by Reed Richards Prime on 2009-05-29 21:23:19
I would suggest to Reed Richards Prime to send a new folio of inking to Marvel/DC/Image/DarkHorse/Moonstone ( especially Moonstone, they DO need inkers ) and Avatar every six months for still, at last five years.

Posted by notapotatoe on 2009-06-02 07:52:20
the gaps in online comics
I personally am not totally satisfied with the answer to the question on why there are gaps in the online comics. While I am currently at a place where obtaining hard copies of comics is not the easiest thing to do, I find it incredibly frustrating to read a 6 series set of comics, only to find that the last two comics are not on the website, and I cant read the ending to the small series. Im convinced there has got to be an answer somewhere.

Posted by dominodude on 2009-06-10 20:31:54
Array
Enter a response to this blog post:
you must log in (or register) in in order to enter a response.
login: password:
subject:

your response:


About this blog:
Ramblings and musings from the mind of Tom Brevoort. "It won’t be clean. It won’t be fun. It mostly won’t be coherent."

About the author:
Tom Brevoort is Executive Editor for Marvel Comics, and oversees such titles as New Avengers, Civil War, and Fantastic Four.
Comics
» Blah Blah Blog by Tom Brevoort - 613 entries
» Blog by Knight by MarvelKnights - 60 entries
» Collected Ramblings by trades department - 75 entries
» Comics for All by Nicole Boose - 28 entries
» Cup of Blog by Joe Quesada - 24 entries
» Dark Tower Blog by The Dark Tower Team - 10 entries
» Panic Room by Mark Paniccia - 9 entries
» Spidey's Web Log by spideyoffice - 12 entries
» Spy in the House by Agent M - 92 entries
» Temple of Atlas by Mr. Lao - 16 entries
» THE NATHAN COSBY BLOG featuring Nate Cosby by Nathan Cosby - 91 entries
» The White Pages by Jordan D. White - 10 entries
» The X-Blog by the X-Office - 16 entries
» Tilting the Scales of Super Hero Justice by Mr. Kemp - 2 entries
» Ultimate Blog by John Barber - 14 entries
» World Wide Webhead by Spider-Office - 66 entries
Marvel.com
» Marvel.com Meta-Blog by pete - 28 entries
Movies
» Ghost Rider Video Blog by ghost rider movie - 25 entries
» spider-man movie blog by spider-man movie - 14 entries
Others
» BLOGDOK by I MODOK - 24 entries
» Ultimate Alliance Blog by Marvel Ultimate Alliance - 1 entries
Video Games
» Blip: the Marvel Games Blog by Marvel Interactive - 27 entries
Marvel News
Marvel Videos
Marvel Digital Comics
All contents ™ and © 2009 Marvel Characters, Inc., unless otherwise noted herein. All rights reserved.