Marvel News
 

News

Movie & TV News

TGIF: Iron Man Reviewed

 
0
 
TGIF: Iron Man Reviewed
Marvel Comics’ creators weigh in with their opinions on Hollywood’s biggest hit of the year—Iron Man

Posted: 2008-05-09    Updated: 2008-05-30 13:31:51


   

 
By Ben Morse

Last weekend, millions of people went, saw and loved every minute of the cinematic experience called "Iron Man"—and if you haven't done the same, do it now!

But not just fans of film and fun turned out for the opening of "Iron Man," so did some of your favorite Marvel creators, so we reached out and asked what they thought of the Armored Avenger's big screen debut.

It's Friday, so kick back, relax and enjoy.
MARK WAID (upcoming writer of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN): Perfect. Note-perfect. The best Marvel movie yet. Robert Downey, Jr. is the single best-cast super hero since Christopher Reeve as Superman, and the humor and humanity he brings to the role of the cool exec with the heart of steel is just remarkable. And on top of all that, the screenplay has one of the best last lines ever.

REGGIE HUDLIN (writer of BLACK PANTHER): I have to see it again. I actually wanted to see it again right after seeing it, but to properly rank it, I need to see it again. To say it is one of the two best films based on a super hero comic book is a safe designation. Best acting ensemble ever in a super hero film. Robert Downey Jr., of course, but Jeff Bridges, who is always great, is so wonderful here. Gwyneth Paltrow is perfectly cast, and of course my man Terence Howard—I can't wait to see him with the armor on!

An amazing debut for Marvel Studios, a triumph for Jon Favreau and the writers, the effects team, and for Hollywood. The sequel can't come soon enough.

GERRY CONWAY (former writer of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN): In my mind, there have been only a handful of really successful super hero movie adaptations. The rest fall into the categories of either "nice try" or "what were you thinking?" But even the best movies have left me with the feeling that they were, well, patched together. By that I mean, there's usually a clear transition from traditional movie making—building character, structuring a story, designing a dramatic arc—to comic book movie making—introducing the super-powers, introducing the costume, introducing the "first night" of action, introducing the super bad guy, etc.

"Iron Man," on the other hand, feels like the first super hero movie I've seen where the transition from traditional movie to super hero movie is so seamless it is, for all practical purposes, invisible. "Iron Man" works as a movie, period. Sure, it's about a guy who builds a red and gold metal suit and fights another guy in a bigger metal suit, but that's like saying "The Maltese Falcon" is about a detective who unravels the mystery of a missing onyx bird. Okay, "Iron Man" may be good, but I admit it's not in [the same league as] "The Maltese Falcon," but you get my point. It's a genre film that somehow lifts itself out of the genre and is a genuine, legitimate story, first and foremost.

What can I say, I liked it. [For more from Gerry, check out his official blog]

ROBERT KIRKMAN (upcoming writer of DESTROYER): "Iron Man" is nearly flawless. It has none of the little bits you have to excuse in most superhero movies. Pepper doesn't get abducted, Tony's helmet doesn't fall off in every scene, there aren't multiple villains who "team-up," it's simply a marvelous movie. With Marvel Studios in charge of the movie, you get a sense that the lunatics are running

the asylum—finally—and it makes for better movies. "Iron Man" is the comic book movie people have been waiting for a long, long time. It's finally here and it's awesome. I'm not even going to mention the spectacular job everyone from Downey Jr. all the way down to Stan Lee did on screen—we've heard about that enough. The writing and directing were outstanding too, but that too has been discussed non-stop. This movie has S.H.I.E.L.D. Agents...'Nuff said! Now, bring on "The Incredible Hulk"!!

JOE KELLY (upcoming writer of AMAZING SPIDER-MAN): I loved it. "Iron Man" has renewed my faith in Hollywood's ability to shepherd our characters to the big screen. Favreau's directing chops are unquestionable, and his genius in casting Downey Jr. shows in every scene. This is the new gold standard.

ANDY SCHMIDT (upcoming writer of X-MEN: DIVIDED WE STAND): Great movie. No qualifiers. No comparison to other "comic book" or "super hero" movies, no "if you're a comic book fan," just a great movie. Entertaining from the opening to the end, well-structured, well-plotted, and extraordinarily well-acted. Downey Jr. and Jeff Bridges elevate this movie from "fun action blockbuster" to great drama and comedy as well. I've recommended it to everyone I know, comic fan or not.

DAVID MICHELINIE (former writer of IRON MAN): I thought Downey sold Tony Stark, and that in turn sold the movie. You believed him, so you believed all the fantastic stuff that was going on around him. The onscreen development and implementation of believable technology was also a major factor. I liked it a lot, and actually plan to spend theater bucks to see it again.

GREG HORN (cover artist of MS. MARVEL): Well first, I thought Robert Downey Jr. was just perfection as Tony Stark. In this role he seemed unnaturally...natural. There were a lot of nay-sayers when he was first cast, but once again we see that you can't complain about a movie until you actually go to the theater and watch it.
Overall, I loved the modern look of this movie. It was fresh and I didn't feel so much like I was watching a remake of something else. Congratulations to Marvel! Your first movie is a smash!!!

JUAN DOE (cover artist of SECRET INVASION: FRONT LINE): I thought "Iron Man" had all the ingredients for a successful movie and it didn't disappoint. For all the cool gadgets and

special effects the movie provided, the bottom line was that this was a story about a man dealing with a change of heart—pun intended—under a life and death situation. The true circumstances of how heroes are born and made. Robert Downey Jr. is now and forever will be Tony Stark.

BRIAN REED (writer of MS. MARVEL): "Iron Man" is a heck of a solid comic book film. There's a willing suspension of disbelief that the audience needs to be convinced to agree with in any action/sci-fi/fantasy film from "Die Hard" to "Star Wars," and like the best of them, "Iron Man" says "and then this happens" and you find yourself just agreeing and going along with it. Of course he builds a glowing electromagnet thing using only spare parts. I believe Tony has robots and a home A.I. that are intelligent enough to understand Tony, and crack wise on occasion. All of the super heroics just flow because the movie makes you believe that even the craziest things are possible.

For the Marvel Zombies out there, holy crap, the sheer number of references that were dropped to other bits of the Marvel Universe—it was staggering. I need to see the film again just to ignore what's happening in the foreground and watch the background.

Oh yeah…almost forgot. Stay till the end of the credits.

BOB LAYTON (former writer/artist of IRON MAN): I think [Robert Downey Jr.] totally nailed the role [of Tony Stark]. I will admit that I had some reservations about him when he was first announced as the actor who would portray Tony Stark but after seeing the movie, I think he was absolutely brilliant!

I know that they changed [the] background [of Jim Rhodes] in the movie from what David [Michelinie] and I originally came up with, but Tony and Jim had the same dynamic onscreen that we gave them in the comics. Jon Favreau stayed true to the spirit of their relationship. I would have liked to find out how they became such great buddies, but I guess that's coming in the next one, eh?

[Overall] I thought it was one of the better comics-to-film adaptations. It'll be a huge boost for my boy Shellhead and his legacy. It's going to help move the character into the consciousness of the general public and not just the comic fans who have respected the character over the decades. Make room for the Armored Avenger!


 

 
Reader Comments:
   

 
This really is a fun little film. And funny too. I laughed more while watching this movie than during the so-called comedies of late (and that includes the ones that I liked). Plus, the portrayal...
Posted By: ComicHeroPerson
 
Truly one of the best comic-to-film adaptions ever made! Quality writing, acting and FX. RDJ is a perfect Tony Stark.
Posted By: johnnysword
 

 

 


More Stuff


blogs
videos
rss feeds
The Weekly Watcher: July 4, 2008
Alexa Mendez celebrates America's Independence with "Punisher: War Zone" and "Next Avengers" movie news, a Wizard World wrap-up, comic book picks and more!
 
Annihilation
The FANTASTIC FOUR fall into a trap and are taken to the NEGATIVE ZONE, where they're attacked by ANNIHILUS and his warriors. But all is not as it seems - something in the Zone is affecting the Four's powers. Things go from bad to worse when DOCTOR DOOM arrives, apparently in league with Annihilus! But Doom isn't one to share power, and he takes Annihilus' energy source back to Earth with him. But even if the Four can escape Annihilus, how can they defeat Doom, who now has the power to destroy the world?
 
Next Avengers: Heroes of Tomorrow Trailer 3
In a world where the evil robot Ultron has wiped out nearly all of humanity—including all the world's heroes—what chance does the next generation of Avengers have against the metallic menace? Check out the third trailer for "Next Avengers: Heroes of Tomorrow"!
 
Smashed: Second Incredible Hulk Movie Trailer
Check out the second theatrical trailer for "The Incredible Hulk," complete with more Hulk and Abomination throwdown goodness, some tender moments and footage of Hulk's signature thunderclap!
 
The Weekly Watcher: June 27, 2008
Alexa Mendez staves off the summer heat with news of the "Wolverine and the X-Men" animated series, Wizard World Chicago and more!
 
Mythos: Captain America Trailer
Experience Captain America's origin in a new way with this special trailer to MYTHOS: CAPTAIN AMERICA by Paul Jenkins and Paolo Rivera!
 
Bait and Switch
While Reed conducts an experiment designed to cure Ben Grimm, there's an energy disruption which causes the experiment to go haywire! Now the Fantastic Four's powers have switched, but they don't have time to get used to them before they have to save the city. Because the energy disruption that caused the accident was the work of Doctor Doom, and now the FF, new powers and all, have to stop Doom before he destroys the city with his scheme.
 
Wolverine and the X-Men Trailer 2
Wolverine leads the X-Men against the a Sentinel assault force in this special "Wolverine and the X-Men" animated series trailer!
 
The Weekly Watcher: June 20, 2008
Alexa Mendez returns from vacation to spread news about "The Incredible Hulk," "Punisher: War Zone," "Spider-Man: Web of Shadows" and more!
 
Impossible
Reed summons one of his deep space probes back to the Baxter Building for repairs, only to find that someone has hitched a ride on it back to Earth: the Impossible Man! The small, impish alien seems harmless enough, but the Fantastic Four soon realize that this creature, who can turn into anything, has turned into a big problem for them! Now they have to figure out how to get the Impossible Man off the planet before he goes from 'annoying' to 'dangerous!'
 
Punisher: War Zone Debut Trailer
Frank Castle's back and he's bigger, meaner and more vengeful than ever! Feast your eyes on the first trailer for December's "Punisher: War Zone" movie right here!
 
The Weekly Watcher: June 13, 2008
What kind of mischief does Alexa Mendez get into on Friday, the 13th? None! She's too busy delivering Incredible Hulk news this week for any shenanigans!
 
Incredible Hulk Fan Q&A, Part 3
"Incredible Hulk" movie director Louis Leterrier answers questions about the film from loyal fans in the final video in this three-part series.
 
Final Incredible Hulk Video Game Trailer
Hulk flexes his muscles—and heroic nature—in the final trailer for "The Incredible Hulk" video game!
 
Incredible Hulk Movie Clip 5
In this stunning clip from "The Incredible Hulk" film, Betty Ross (Liv Tyler) pleads with Bruce Banner (Edward Norton) not to face the Abomination. Thankfully, she fails!
 
Puppet Master
When a cosmic-ray saturated piece of the Fantastic Four's space station falls to earth on the Jersey Shore, the clay of eccentric local sculptor Phillip Masters, becomes energized with the power to control the minds and actions of others. The sculptor becomes THE PUPPET MASTER and uses miniature clay versions of the Fantastic Four to control the real heroes. Puppet Master captures award-winning New York artists, including his own step-daughter, Alicia, in an attempt to take over his "rightful place" in the art world.
 
Alex Ross on Avengers/Invaders and More
AVENGERS/INVADERS architect and cover artist Alex Ross stops by the Marvel office to talk about his latest project with the House of Ideas, his influences and what lies ahead!
 
Making of the Incredible Hulk Video Game
Go behind the scenes with the creators of "The Incredible Hulk" video game, along with Marvel staffers and the incomparable Stan Lee to get a first-hand look at the making of the newest Hulk game!
 
On the Green Carpet: Incredible Hulk Premiere
Marvel.com was on the green carpet for the star-studded Hollywood premiere of "The Incredible Hulk" movie. Check out our video coverage!
 
The Weekly Watcher: All-Hulk Special Edition
Alexa Mendez goes green for this very special all-Hulk edition of the Weekly Watcher! Get all the info you need on the "Incredible Hulk" movie, toys, video games, comic books and more!